Your products and product designs are the lifeblood of your business. However, many companies don’t think about protecting their creative product designs and product packaging with intellectual property registrations.
This article highlights some major things you should consider as you launch your products into the marketplace from an intellectual property perspective. Various forms of intellectual property protection are available in the form of copyrights, trademarks, trade dress, and design patents. Let’s look at these. This is general legal information only and not legal advice.
Copyright Protection For Product Packaging And Product Design
- Creative Food Containers
- Pizza Box Design
- Creative Product Packaging Designs (cereal box art, board game boxes)
- Wine Labels
- Jewelry (ex. patent designs)
Basically, anything that has a minimum level of creativity (uniquenesses not required) and is more than just an assembly of shapes may qualify for copyright protection and allow the rights-holder to enjoin any substantially similar product that seeks to copy, distribute, and/or reproduce the protected product packaging and allow the rights-holder to seek monetary damages for lost profits or statutory damages of up to $150,000 for willful infringement.
NOTE: Copyright cannot protect functional/utilitarian items (ex. a lamp). The original creative expression (i.e. a creative lampshade) must be separable from the utility to be copyrightable. If you have something “artsy” about your product, consider copyright protection.
Registration with the United States Copyright Office (“USCO”) is very inexpensive and generally takes about 6 months, but expedited registration is available, for example, if you need to go to litigation, or to the newly created “Copyright Small Claims Board” in Washington D.C.
Miscellaneous Points About Copyright Protection For Product Packaging And Product Design
How long does copyright protection last? It depends on the authorship, but the life of the author plus 70 years, or 95 to 120 years. This is substantial protection for a long period of time, even after the author of the work is deceased.
Registration of copyright also allows you to sue copyright infringers in federal court and seek actual damages or statutory damages, plus attorney fees.
Other examples of things that can be copyrighted: fabric designs, original design for a shampoo bottle, water bottle, or beer bottle. Maps, architectural designs, diagrams, models, maps, globes, photographs, and any art or prints. Creative aspects of clothing can also be protected (ex. cheerleader and sports outfit).
Ideas and facts cannot be copyrighted.
Anytime your product packaging is creative, consider copyright protection.
Corporate logos: You can also copyright your corporate logo, product logos, and creative characters on your packaging. Also, (see below), your logos and product slogans can be trademark registered.
Trademark Protection For Product Packaging And Product Designs
Any logos and slogans used in conjunction with your brand can also be trademarked. Acquiring a trademark provides for nationwide rights (subject to prior uses that may exist). Trademarks are often thought of as (a) traditional trademarks and (b) non-traditional trademarks.
(a) traditional trademarks (ex. words, phrases, logos, symbols, slogans, that identify the source of the goods) can be trademarked. These can become very valuable corporate assets.
(b) non-traditional trademarks
Many don’t know that other things can be trademarked, such as colors (Pink Fibreglass), sounds (McDonalds “I’m lovin’ it”), and even scents (Strawberry toothbrushes). Product configurations that identify the source of goods can also be trademarked. For example, (the kiss chocolate candy design represents the Hershey’s company as the source of goods):
Any creative feature of your product design that identifies your company as the source of goods can be potentially trademarked, giving nationwide rights as long as the mark is being used in commerce. These IP rights can last forever as long as they are used in commerce.
Once again, functional aspects are not protected by trademark law. For functional/utilitarian items, look to patent protection. In some cases, an applicant for the product design/packaging trademark may have to prove “secondary meaning” (i.e. that consumers recognize the product configuration as coming from your company). This may take some time to accomplish, and you may need to market your product for a few years before applying for the mark.
Other product trademark examples:
- Jewelry (David Yerman) product design.
Mark Drawing Code: (2) DESIGN ONLY
Design Search Code: 14.01.03 – Cables, electrical, With electric plugs ; Cords, electrical (with plugs) ; Electrical wire/cables, With plug ; Plugs, electrical
Serial Number: 86064049
- Chair Design
BOTTOM LINE: If your product design is unique to your company, the design can potentially be trademarked, giving you rights to enjoin any company selling a confusingly similar design. Again, proof of “secondary meaning” (significant sales, press recognition, etc.) may be required to show the product design is inherently distinctive and, thus, protectable.
Trade Dress Protection For Distinctive Designs (like a trademark)
Non-functional and inherently distinctive Trade dress is an often-unknown form of IP protection. Like seeking a trademark for your company logos, slogans, and other “source-identifiers,” trade dress protection can potentially last forever. Trade dress protects the look and feel of product packaging that has “secondary meaning” to consumers and prohibits competing product packaging that presents a “likelihood of consumer confusion.”
Trade dress must be “distinctive” (more than just “original” like copyrights, and more than “new, useful and non-obvious,” like patents) which means that consumers must be able to readily identify your product package as coming from just one source or just one business that manufactures the good or service. The standard for infringement is “substantial similarity.”
Some types of things that might be available for trade dress protection include:
- KFC chicken buckets and color schemes (ex. The KFC restaurant red/white color scheme)
- Textures (ex. Coco Cola bottle with its ribs and curves)
- Box & Packaging Designs (ex. Kleenex, Band-Aid, Oreo cookies, Godiva chocolate box)
Jack Daniel’s bottle design:
Word Mark: JACK DANIEL JACK DANIEL
Goods and Services: IC 033. US 047 049. G & S: Alcoholic beverages, namely, distilled spirits. FIRST USE: 20110630. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 20110630
Mark Drawing Code: (3) DESIGN PLUS WORDS, LETTERS, AND/OR NUMBERS
Design Search Code: 19.09.03 – Bottles, jars or flasks with straight, vertical sides ; Flasks with straight or vertical sides ; Jars with straight or vertical sides
Serial Number: 85018906
Published for Opposition: November 2, 2010
Registration Number: 4106178
Design Patent Protection For Product Packaging And Product Design
Non-functional/non-utility product packaging can also be subject of a design patent if it is deemed “new, useful, and non-obvious.” These must be approved by the USPTO (United States Patent and Trademark Office). Design patents last 15 years. After that, other competitors can make, use or sell similar designs. In other words, this is a “limited monopoly” of 15 years.
There are also time limitations. A company only has up to one year to seek a patent design after the design is released to the public. If it doesn’t, then they will be unable to claim design patent rights in that design. The test for infringement of a design patent is similar to copyright law, where a substantially similar design may be the subject of legal action.
Sample product/packaging designs that have applied for, and received “design patent” protection from the United States Patent & Trademark Office
- Electronic Device Design
- Combination Tool Design
- Folding Stove
- Animal Toys
- Brush Design
Bottom line: If you have any ornamental features to your product, and those are new, useful, and non-obvious, you may be able to obtain a limited 15-year monopoly to prevent others from making, using, or selling similar designs that may confuse the “ordinary observer.” Penalties and damages are also possible against infringers.
You can expect design patents to take over 20 months to procure, so proper planning is important.
Conclusion
These are just a few examples to be thinking about when you are creating and launching a product, and it contains creative packaging or creative and unique product designs. There are various forms of intellectual property available to consider with a qualified IP law firm.
Remember, when you go to Shark Tank to pitch your product and the “sharks” or investors ask, “Is there anything proprietary here,” it is nice to say, “Yes, sharks, we have a design patent, copyrights, trademarks, and trade dress protection.”
If you need legal assistance, including arbitration and litigation, contact us at (877) 276-5084 or visit us at VondranLegal.com.
